Following the Knicks' most recent loss to a mediocre team, 99-95 to the Pistons, it is time for another major change. At 6-6 since their big trade the Knicks can no longer make excuses as they have done all season. Team president Donnie Walsh has done his job in bringing two max level stars to New York, those two stars have done their job combining to average over 50 points, 14 rebounds, and five assists. Even the bench, which supposedly is the weakest part of the team, has some solid ancillary pieces in Shawne Williams, Toney Douglas and Bill Walker. That leaves only one piece that isn't working right: The Coach.
I have been a big D'Antoni fan since his days in Phoenix. I like his style. It's fun to watch and with the right players can win. The problem is that the Knicks don't have the right players. It worked in Phoenix because the Suns had Steve Nash in his prime to perfectly run the offense along some great individual defenders (Shawn Marion, Raja Bell, Boris Diaw etc) to cover up for the horrific team defense. Unfortunately for New York it would be virtually impossible for them to go through another major roster overhaul to get a slew of elite defenders. That means they have to start playing some at least passable team defense which you can't and won't get from coach Mike.
Take a look at some of the best defense teams in the NBA (Chicago, Orlando, San Antonio) they all play stifling defense without having great defenders from top to bottom. In fact some of those teams have some really bad defenders in their starting lines: Hedo Turkoglu, Richard Jefferson, Derrick Rose, Tony Parker, Jameer Neslon - the list goes on. They all also have two things the Knick's do not a big man who can hold his own (Jared Jeffries does not count) and a coach who understands the importance of defense. The Knicks are garunteed to make a bid for a starting center this summer when Tyson Chandler, Nene and Marc Gasol are all available. That will not be enough. The need Mike D'Antoni out. Completely. He is holding NYK back from being a real contender. While nothing can be now with playoffs right around the corner, if Jimmy Dolan wants real success he'll get a new coach this offseason. Tough but fair.






